Film Reviewing Film Criticism

RSS
Welcome to Madinkbeard. If you enjoy this post you could subscribe to the RSS feed to receive upcoming posts or browse the archives to see past posts. I also create webcomics.
January 1st, 2008
Categories: Comics, TV and Film

Explaining anything involves analyzing it, at least to some degree. Analysis is a matter of breaking up whole phenomena into relevant parts and showing how they work together. [...] An academic film critic will divide a film into parts (scenes, sequences, “acts”) to see how the overall architecture works. Explaining something also involves describing it. [...] An academic film critic will describe a scene in detail, for that’s necessary to understanding why it carries a particular meaning or achieves a particular effect. Analysis and description are rare in ordinary conversation and in film reviewing because of limits of time and space, but also because the film scholar is interested in something that isn’t so pressing for other parties: explanations.

David Bordwell. “Studying Cinema” (2000) on the difference between ordinary film conversation/film reviewing and film criticism.

Read more about: , ,

Related Posts

  1. Dan Green on Academic Criticism
  2. Bordwell on Criticism
  3. Film style changes
  4. Analytical criticism
  5. On Criticism by Noel Carroll
  6. Best Comics Criticism of 2007 2
  7. Reviews v Criticism
  8. Best Comics Criticism of 2007
  9. Douglas Wolk on Criticism
  10. Making Meaning Notes

Leave a Reply